• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Frugal Gardening

Simple ways to save money while you garden

  • About
  • Contact Us
  • Garden Frugally
  • Buy These
  • Privacy Policy
  • Navigation Menu: Social Icons

    • Facebook
    • Pinterest
    • Twitter

5 Cheap Substitutes for Seedling Trays

March 22, 2022 by Kathryn Vercillo 2 Comments

Substitutes for Seedling Trays

Seed trays offer a great way to start off your planting season. However, you don’t need to purchase actual trays from the gardening supply store. Instead, you can upcycle/recycle/DIY many terrific substitutes for seedling trays. Here are five good ideas:

What Are Seedling Trays?

Seed trays provide a great opportunity to begin growing multiple plants from seed at once. You germinate a bunch of them together in the trays. Then, when they’re ready to go into pots or the ground, you transplant them. This allows you to start your planting season early, beginning plant growing inside until it’s warm enough for outdoor planting.

Cheap Substitutes for Seedling Trays

You can easily purchase seedling trays. There are many different varieties, made of different materials, and in the come in a huge range of sizes. However, there’s really no need to purchase these when it’s so easy to make substitutes for seedling trays yourself.

1. Egg Cartons

Egg cartons provide one of the best substitutes for seedling trays. First of all, you probably already have some. If not, ask your neighbors for theirs. Therefore, this doesn’t cost anything.

Second, as Treehugger explains, these are biodegradable. Therefore, when you’re ready to move the seeds from the tray to the ground, all that you need to do is cut apart the egg carton and bury each section in the soil. In other words, you don’t have to take the seed out of the tray at all.

Furthermore, if you still have your egg shells, then you can include those as part of the planting process. Leave half an eggshell in each cup of the egg carton. Plant the seeds inside of those. You get great nutrients and don’t waste those eggshells.

2. DIY Newspaper Pots

Treehugger also notes that you can do the same thing with DIY newspaper pots. Make them yourself with recycled newspaper glued together with wheat paste. Plant the seeds in the pots. Then, when it’s time, plant the pots into the soil. You can put each pot next to another inside of a cardboard box while the seeds are germinating.

3. Cardboard Coffee Cups

If you regularly purchase coffee to go, then you might be able to quickly accrue a bunch of cardboard coffee cups. Ask your friends if you need extras. Fill them with soil, poke some holes in the bottom for good drainage, put them into an upcycled box, and you have a seedling tray.

Country Living points out that you can use empty K-cups in the same manner.

4. Toilet Paper Roll Tubes

Basically, any cardboard or paper that you can fashion into a pot-like vessel can work. Therefore, both Country Living and Treehugger mention the common hack of using paper towel or toilet paper tubes. You fold one end to keep the soil inside, fill it with soil and the seed, and place into an empty box. Note: there are several alternatives for folding over the one end. For example, wrap the whole thing in brown paper bags.

5. Halved Citrus Rinds

Here is the most interesting suggestion from Country Living. Take a lemon, lime, orange, or grapefruit and cut it in half. Juice it and enjoy the juice. Poke a few holes in the bottom for drainage. Then fill the center with soil and plant your seed in there. When it’s time to plant, just bury the whole thing in the soil in your garden.

Read More:

  • Seed Starting on a Budget: DIY Containers
  • Don’t Throw Those Pots Away
  • Buying Seedlings: Getting Your Money’s Worth

 

Kathryn Vercillo
Kathryn Vercillo

Kathryn Vercillo is a long time writer, crafter and author of several books. A resident of San Francisco, she is committed to helping others explore, articulate and share their own individuals stories. When she’s not evaluating investing opportunities Kathryn is an avid knitter, researcher, and blogger.

Filed Under: seedlings, seeds Tagged With: DIY, diy seedling trays, seed pots, seed trays

Previous Post: « A Garden to Dye For
Next Post: Garden Photo Walks for Mindfulness »

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Ruth

    March 23, 2022 at 7:03 am

    I read to save you to rolls as they make excellent seed starters. Just cut four cuts about 3 inches from one side. Set them in a tray. Make a bottom by folding them up, fill them with soil and seeds and water. Place in the tray and plant them to tube and all….

    Reply
    • Kathryn Vercillo

      April 4, 2022 at 4:35 pm

      Definitely a great option!

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Struggling to get your garden off the ground? Put those days behind you with our special starter kit – perfect for thrifty green thumbs everywhere. Get growing and add a splash of color today!

Popular Posts

  • usda free seeds websiteHow To Get Free Seeds From The Government by Amanda Blankenship Seeds might seem like a small expense, but any seasoned…
  • Enviro Ice On PlantsShould I Use Enviro Ice On My Plants? by Kathryn Vercillo Every week, I receive food from Hungryroot. It's a great…
  • is shredded paper good for the gardenFrom Trash to Treasure: Transform Shredded Paper Into Garden Gold by Amanda Blankenship Should you use shredded paper as garden mulch? It might…
  • Enviro IceWhat Happens to Plants If You Use Enviro Ice on Them? by Amanda Blankenship About a year ago, I wrote our first article about…
The “Hardening Off” Mistake That Leads to Transplant Failure

The “Hardening Off” Mistake That Leads to Transplant Failure

Spring excitement hits fast in the garden world. Seedlings look strong indoors, leaves stretch toward light, and everything feels ready for the big outdoor debut. Then the plants hit real-world conditions—wind, sun, temperature swings—and suddenly collapse like they never knew the garden life existed. That dramatic flop often traces back to one overlooked step: hardening…

Read More

8 Pollinator-Friendly Additions That Increase Garden Activity

8 Pollinator-Friendly Additions That Increase Garden Activity

A garden can transform from quiet and still into a buzzing, fluttering ecosystem with just a few intentional changes. Bees zigzag through blossoms, butterflies drift like living confetti, and hummingbirds zip in like tiny helicopters on a mission. The secret does not lie in expensive landscaping or complicated designs, but in thoughtful additions that invite…

Read More

5 Container Garden Ideas That Work on Small Balconies

5 Container Garden Ideas That Work on Small Balconies

A tiny balcony does not need to limit gardening dreams. In fact, small spaces often spark the most creative, productive, and eye-catching gardens. With the right containers, plant choices, and layout tricks, even a narrow balcony can transform into a lush mini oasis bursting with color and flavor. Every inch matters, and smart gardening turns…

Read More

Why Growth Stalls Even When Conditions Seem Perfect

Why Growth Stalls Even When Conditions Seem Perfect

Gardens often tell a strange story. Everything looks right on the surface, yet progress suddenly slows without warning. Leaves stop stretching, stems lose their energy, and blooms hesitate as if waiting for permission that never arrives. Even carefully tended spaces can hit invisible roadblocks that confuse and frustrate gardeners. The secret often hides beneath what…

Read More

  • About
  • Contact Us
  • Garden Frugally
  • Buy These
  • Privacy Policy
  • Navigation Menu: Social Icons

    • Facebook
    • Pinterest
    • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter

Copyright © 2026 · Foodie Pro & The Genesis Framework